Amaranth Marketplace – Amaranth, Community Marketplace for the buying and selling of Pagan, Wiccan, Occult, Ritual, New Age, Metaphysical & Spiritual Tools & Supplies.
Scott’s Marketplace – US based businesses only. Seem to be lots of handmade items as well as some Pagan items there. They charge a 4.99% FVF – no listing fees or monthly fees.
BluJay – 100% Free Marketplace
eCrater – Another selling site.
Atomic Mall – Selling site